Except—well, not ice cream. Because the Food and Drug Administration just recalled 16,000 gallons of it. Wait, what? Yeah, I’m right there with you. How does ice cream even get recalled? Apparently, if it contains plastic.

Wells Enterprises, which oversees brands including Blue Bunny, Halo Top, and Johnny Rockets, is recalling multiple tubs of ice cream and frozen yogurt products because of potential plastic contamination.

According to an enforcement report published by the FDA, Wells Enterprises, which produces Wells Dairy products, issued a voluntary recall of 22 flavors of frozen desserts in their portfolio. The FDA's report states that the Iowa-based company commenced its recall on April 25 and was classified in the organization's system on Wednesday, May 14.