For young drivers: USAA* and Geico, $244 and $266 respectively For middle-aged drivers: Geico, $136 For senior drivers: Geico, $139 Cheapest by driving record For drivers with an at-fault accident: ...

WSJ Buy Side is The Wall Street Journal’s research and commerce team. Our commerce content is distinct from our newsroom coverage. We earn a commission from some links in our articles. Learn more.